Milk Dud's vs. Reese's - A tie in our first competition! Tiebreaker went to Dave, since Bob was eating dinner. He chose Milk Dud's for their in your face taste.
Skittles vs. York - York. Hands down, this was an easy one.
Nerds vs. Nibs - Nibs. We're on a roll now!
Tootsie Roll vs. Caramello - Caramello wins for it's smooth caramel center and overall satisfaction levels.
Peanut M&M vs. Heath - This one went into tie-breaker where Bob, after much deliberation, chose Peanut M&M's.
3 Musketeers vs. Snickers - Those 3 Musketeers ran straight back to France after this football branded Snickers kicked them out of the ballpark. (Do you like my mixed sports metaphors?)
Skor vs. Sugar Babies - I voted against Skor, Jamey voted for. In tie-breaker, Skor was the easy winner.
Swedish Fish vs. KitKat - Here we diverge for the history of the name KitKat, and KitKat wins.
Whatchamacallit - We both randomly got green Dots, but they didn't hold up to the hidden joy of the Whatchamacallit!
Butterfinger vs. Peanut Butter M&M's - This round went into tie-breaker... Peanut Butter M&M's reign triumphantly!
Gummy Worms vs. SweetTarts - I got a blue tart, Jamey got a red one; but still the gummy/i trumped!
Twix vs. Mr. Goodbar - Mr. Goodbar only made it into this round because it is Bob's favorite candy, though quite disgusting. Incidentally, there was something wrong with the Twix bar, so the vote was unanimously Mr. Goodbar.
Almond Joy vs. Nutroll - Almond Joy, easy peasy.
100 Grand vs. Starburst - The Starburst were the blue 'California' flavors, and easily defeated the 100 Grand bar.
PayDay vs. Charleston Chew - Mmmmm.... Charleston Chew! Better frozen, but still enough to beat the PayDay.
Jr. Mint vs. Good & Plenty - G&P's, one of my all time favorite candies, but mint is Jamey's lover. So it went into a tiebreaker round.... Where Bob betrayed me by voting for Jr. Mints.
Here is Grant, ridiculously happy to be eating the loser candies. (Only Dots did he call candy, and he dropped Nerds around him everywhere. Needless to say, my dogs followed him like slaves all night long.)
Here we have Jamey and Dave with the empty tournament bracket. They are obviously ecstatic to have a night of binge candy eating ahead of them...
Check soon for the next round of the candy tournament!!!